The Obsessive's Myth of Control

Originally published by: PEP

Introduction

Among patients in psychotherapy who are markedly obsessive in personality style (APA, 1980), certain psychological characteristics strike the author as particularly prevalent and important. They include an inordinate need for control; perfectionism; a significantly impaired ability to trust; conflict around dependency; fear of being “found out”; and an idiosyncratic response to perceived demands. Many of the specific traits thought typical of obsessives (stubbornness, ambivalence, orderliness, indecisiveness, stinginess, etc.) derive from and organize themselves around these core issues.

Of these central issues, the one most basic, pervasive, evident and clinically significant is the need for control. The obsessional’s need for control includes (a) control of his own feelings, behavior, physical integrity, psychological cohesion and sense of identity; (b) control of others’ opinions, attitudes and actions towards him and of their physical and emotional proximity to him; and (c) control over the myriad miscellaneous events that might affect him, including death.

This paper discusses theoretical and clinical aspects of the obsessive’s exaggerated need for control. Specifically, it (1) suggests and describes the evolution of a nuclear defensive myth about attaining total control; (2) describes the obsessional’s driven pursuit of confirmation for his myth and clinical consequences of this quest; (3) delineates symptoms occurring whenever the myth “fails”; (4) describes a mechanism utilized to gain an illusory retroactivecontrol; (5) organizes the pursuit of control into three arenas - the self, others, and miscellaneous experiences - and discusses clinical manifestations in each.

This work attempts to enhance the clinician’s understanding of this difficult patient by organizing and clarifying a single aspect of the obsessional’s complex psychological life. Particularly highlighted are cognitive factors - the ways in which the obsessive’s conscious and unconscious idiosyncratic beliefs about control manifest themselves in rather typical behavioral patterns, some of which damage him.

The pursuit of control serves an adaptive function in a survival-of-species sense and in the life of the individual. This paper addresses aspects of the pursuit that, in some individuals, seem inordinate, inflexible and, ultimately, self-damaging.

The obsessional tends to pursue control over himself and his universe relentlessly and rigidly, as an end. Deep fears may prevent him from envisioning or exercising control flexibly, as one of many partial means toward creative, productive and enjoyable living. Even when the “in-complete-control” psychological posture is inappropriate, when a more receptive, passively experiential, or spontaneous mode might deepen and enrich his experience (e.g., moments of intimacy, pleasure, relaxation and aesthetic receptivity), he finds it difficult or impossible to shift.

Before a discussion of theoretical and clinical issues, two qualifications deserve mention: (1) comments on childhood perceptions were derived from memories of adult patients, not from direct observations of children; (2) this paper’s function is mainly descriptive - it attempts merely to delineate and elaborate for the clinician a single, already-known facet of obsessional living. It does not propose to explain all aspects of the obsessional style, nor does it offer a specific therapeutic approach.

In the first part of this paper there will be some brief comments on pertinent literature, followed by theoretical remarks about the etiology of the inordinate pursuit of control. In the second section, clinical phenomena are described and discussed.

Theoretical Considerations

Literature

Freud (1908) viewed the essential features of the obsessional character - orderliness, parsimony and obstinacy - as derivatives of infantile anal-erotic impulses and their associated defenses. He did not focus upon the need for control, intra- or interpersonal, as a discrete clinical entity. Orthodox theorists (Jones, 1918; Abraham, 1921; Fenichel, 1945) accepted and extended this etiologic formulation.

Later writers have tended to depart from libido theory, stressing cultural over instinctual motives (Shapiro, 1965; Rado, 1969; Barnett, 1972; Adams, 1973). They emphasize the impact of interpersonal learning upon the child’s ideas - about himself, others, their relatedness, and his universe in general. Based on these ideas, the child utilizes certain safety-seeking and security-seeking (adaptive) maneuvers. Along with impulse-gratification behaviors, these specific adaptive maneuvers can become keystones of personality traits. In some people, the main adaptive maneuvers are traits that have become known as obsessive.

Salzman’s view (1968) surpasses earlier theory in recognizing and attempting to explain the need for both illusion and control in obsessional behavior. In this view obsessional characteristics, including perfectionism and indecision, for example, represent multifaceted attempts at control, as the obsessive struggles for an illusory guarantee of safety and security in a potentially dangerous universe. Some of the present author’s central findings, independently reached through work with his own patients, agree closely with some of Salzman’s, especially with regard to the core defensive role of control dynamics. While Salzman’s work is clinical and broad, this paper attempts a more concentrated, comprehensive discussion of one aspect of theory, including etiology.

Etiology

Like many other patients, the obsessive seems to have been frightened in childhood by feelings of helplessness and vulnerability relative to life’s uncertainties and potential dangers. Apparently this child feels especially sensitive to unpredictable, powerful or hostile forces experienced as constantly threatening both from within and without - forces over which he feels powerless.

Inside are his own forbidden, disapproved of, or dangerous impulses and desires. He may also sense and fear the possibility of somehow losing his sense of self, disappearing, or even disintegrating, literally flying into a million pieces!

Dangers from the outside are perceived in two major areas, interpersonal and miscellaneous. Potential interpersonal dangers include rejection, disapproval, abandonment, betrayal, humiliation, loss of nurturance, domination, having one’s sense of identity swallowed up, overwhelmed, or intruded upon, and physically damaging interaction. Miscellaneous external dangers, on the other hand, are not particularly personal. They include accidents, injury, illness and death.

Gradually, the child attenuates these fears somewhat by developing controls, however limited, in all three experiential areas. He counters the feared inner forces, for example, by the development and utilization, not only of defense mechanisms, such as repression and reaction formation, but also of an increasing ability to reason, and other conscious measures. These include asking questions, imitating adults, and consciously suppressing frightening or risky thoughts, feelings and actions.

The pre-obsessive child may combat interpersonal fears, in part, by the development of expertise in interpersonal diplomacy and opinion-moulding maneuvers; by the use of such self-protective patterns as compulsive autonomy, secrecy, emotional distancing, evasiveness and passivity; and by putting others on the defensive by being judgmental, righteous, or hard to please.

He even gains some control over miscellaneous, or impersonal, dangers - injury, illness, etc. - by adopting a cautious, vigilant or anticipatory psychological posture relative to life’s possible events, and by exercising a certain amount of denial.

Yet, the pre-obsessive child, perhaps more than other children, is kept anxious by the continuing awareness that in each area his control is only partial or imperfect. It disturbs him that many of the potential dangers listed above are not totally under his control and, therefore, unpredictable. To him, imperfect control is hardly better than none at all.

This perception is particularly poignant in his relationships with valued others, such as his parents. This experiential area carries special educative impact. After all, to the infant and small child, survival itself depends upon these relationships. And here, for whatever reasons, the pre-obsessional child concludes that he cannot rely upon a consistent general benevolence in the behavior of his world towards him, nor can he trust his own perceptions and predictions. Too often the real effects of parental actions strike him as contradicting professed intentions or verbal messages. He becomes convinced, at some level, that those who determine his survival and well-being cannot be trusted to feel and act towards him in a consistently and predictably positive fashion. In addition, parental communications that are chronically ambiguous, inconsistent, or contradictory may confuse him about himself, about his parents’ feelings, and about how the universe runs in general. Thus, not only does the child doubt his parents - he doubts himself. Consequently, he continues to feel incapable of competently controlling his own destiny.

Doubts engendered in the family extend not only to his other human relationships, but to all aspects of his life. He cannot trust external reality in general to be consistent, essentially benevolent, or even benign towards him; thus, nothing can be left to chance. This conviction, coupled with doubt about his own competence to apprehend, predict and control his experiences, keeps him on the verge of intolerable anxiety which, like Karen Horney’s “basic anxiety” (1945), must be resolved if the child is to navigate sanely through life.

The pre-obsessive child seems to attempt a solution by repressing his frightening private reality and substituting a defensive irrational belief in his own potential omnipotence. (By defensive belief, I mean any conviction whose purpose is to minimize anxiety by unconsciously distorting or decreasing the perception of reality.) Somehow, he elaborates the following myth: “If I try hard enough, I can maintain control over anything and everything that might affect me, and thus protect myself from all potential dangers. I can control my own thoughts, feelings, and actions; the opinions, attitudes and behaviors of relevant others towards me; and the miscellaneous potential dangers in life, such as illness, accidents, misfortune and even death! Furthermore, through discovering and understanding basic formulae governing its behavior, I can control my universe, human and nonhuman, by seeing its order and predictability.”

The child then clings to this conviction in order to avoid anxiety connected with his underlying feelings of life-threatening uncertainty and powerlessness. Illusory or not, this defensive belief becomes a nucleus around which is elaborated a key segment of the obsessional’s emotional life and personality style. In fact, much of his day-to-day behavior can be understood as partly deriving from a quest to confirm his myth. Repeatedly, in his various interpersonal and intrapsychic maneuvers, he seeks to prove to himself that his special ability to control his life and avert potential dangers is in good repair.

As with any major defensive belief, confirming experience promotes a transient sense of well-being, and nonconfirming experience evokes anxiety, unless the experience is successfully distorted into confirmation. These distortions occur by virtue of such mechanisms as selective attention, denial, rationalization and even retroactivemaneuvers, to be discussed later. Should distorting fail, leaving the individual to face the possible inaccuracy of his nuclear defensive belief, anxiety persists. Unmodified, the situation may culminate in depression if the obsessional becomes convinced of the inaccuracy of his nuclear defensive belief, or if he is biologically vulnerable to mood swings.

In time, the control myth becomes more than just a nuclear defense against anxiety. It becomes a building block in the obsessional’s solidifying sense of self, and eventually, of self-esteem and pride. He comes to invest, overly value, or idealize his spurious potential omnipotence as a treasured part of his identity. This valuing is spurred by his perception of his parents’ attitudes. He perceives them as giving approval when he exhibits control and mastery, and disapproval when he yields to impulses and feelings.

However, when self-esteem rests heavily upon defensive convictions, it topples easily. Thus, experiences that challenge the control myth evoke anxiety for a second reason: they place the obsessive’s sense of self-esteem in jeopardy. If the experience inescapably contradicts the myth, a sudden drop in self-esteem may occur. Should other people be present during such an episode, he may also feel humiliated. The obsessional seems particularly susceptible to this cognitive-affective state, and much of his behavior represents an attempt to avoid it. (In this paper, “pride” refers to an expansive affective state accompanying an expectation that one will begin or continue to receive the wished-for esteem of one or more valued others by virtue of some act, affiliation, capacity or trait. Humiliation is approximately its opposite, i.e., a markedly dysphoric affective state triggered by a, usually sudden, perceived catastrophic drop in the esteem of others. To the degree that pride rests upon distortedly perceived, spurious, fragile or transient qualities in oneself, and upon the perceived or real opinions of others, it is fragile; and proportionally, the experience of humiliation is chronically imminent and defended against.)

To summarize: Often the markedly obsessive therapy client seems to have wrestled in early childhood with feelings of powerlessness and inadequacy in a world of internal and external forces perceived as dangerously uncontrollable, unpredictable, untrustworthy, and essentially malevolent. Particularly manifest within the context of early relationships, this style of perceiving later becomes generalized to include the universe in abstract. Development of some controls on all experiential fronts is helpful but insufficient to stem the child’s anxiety, and a nuclear defensive conviction evolves as a “solution.”

This conviction asserts that the child ultimately can control himself and the things that happen to him; thus, he can guarantee his own safety and interpersonal security. While it decreases his anxiety tremendously, the defensive myth is not entirely successful. First, the child (and later the adult) seeks constant, repetitive confirmation, which frequently requires further distortions. Further, when confirmation is impossible, anxiety and/or a variety of other symptoms can occur. In addition, the obsessive constructs a major portion of his sense of, first, self and, then, self-esteem around this spurious ability to control.

Clinical Considerations - Pursuing The Myth

We shall divide clinical aspects of the obsessional’s pursuit of the control myth into the three areas mentioned earlier - control over himself, over others, and over miscellaneous life experiences.

Control over Himself

The obsessional strives to maintain a sense of control over his own feared thoughts, feelings and behaviors, and over a fear of coming apart psychologically. To accomplish this, he uses both unconscious and conscious means. Unconscious maneuvers include such defense mechanisms as repression, reaction-formation, denial, intellectualization, and externalization. When utilized extensively, these can render him genuinely unaware of many of his feelings. In fact, sometimes he wrongly concludes that he lacks an essential capacity that others seem to possess, one which allows them to respond emotionally. Consequently he may feel defective, or alien to those around him, and may fear discovery. Wishing to seem “normal,” he may fake whatever feelings he thinks are appropriate in various situations. Or conversely, to compensate for his perceived defect, he may idealize it. If so, he will disdain feelings as signs of weakness; he will overvalue cerebration and reason, and deride “emotionalism” and emotional people.

He may also pursue a near-caricature of self-discipline. This can take the form of self-denial, asceticism, a stubborn, task-related perseverance, or an untempered, ultimately destructive, frankness or honesty. In appropriate amounts at appropriate times, of course, these can be admirable qualities. But in the unyielding quest to establish and maintain complete control over his body, thoughts and emotions, the obsessive may carry virtues to self-destructive extremes. For example, he might deny himself a needed break from study or work. He fears that if he lets his control slip just this once, he will have less self-control the next time, and still less thereafter, that ultimately he will lose totally his hard-won self-discipline and become paralyzed or helpless, unable to make himself accomplish anything. This possibility is especially frightening because of his often desperate need to achieve. If he lapses while dieting or trying to quit smoking or drinking, he is distraught, not so much because he may become obese, drunk, or ill, but rather because he was unable to control himself, unable to make himself do what he had decided he should do. The obsessive also fears that now he has set a precedent that may tempt him again in the future. A typical complaint at this point is that he is no longer sure he can “trust” himself to do as he says he will, and this frightens him.

Control over Others

Control over others refers here to an exaggerated or inflexible need to (a) influence favorably the opinions of others toward oneself; (b) be the one who determines the initiation, termination, time, place and content of any interaction between oneself and others; (c) avoid or terminate situations in which one feels controlled by others; and (d) direct the courses of action of others, as in administrative, political or economic positions of control.

These four types of control over others overlap, and each is multidetermined. Characteristic behavior patterns are always “funnels”: to accommodate the pressure of thousands of early needs, fears, conflicts and perceptions, the child develops relatively few coordinated sets of adaptive behaviors and attitudes (“solutions”). These are shaped and limited by his specific constitutional equipment and by the values of his subculture and family.

The obsessive’s solutions or adaptations form rather stable nuclei around which personality characteristics crystallize; that is, relatively fixed patterns are incorporated into the ongoing construction of the child’s cognitive/emotional/behavioral style. In the service of efficient psychological function, a given characteristic later serves as a final common pathway for the expression of several other, sometimes unrelated, motives as well. Various motives are thus expressed in an economical form, one that is consistent with the already laid-down personality. (One major source of difficulty in attempting to modify a behavioral characteristic is the fact that it may smoothly serve many and varied motivational aims.)

For example, the obsessional’s attempt to control others is discussed below as if it stemmed from a single source - the need to confirm the myth that he can control everything that happens to him. In truth, though, many fears, beliefs, needs, and other factors contribute. Issues such as trust, self-esteem, innate temperament and role models, for instance, can all contribute to the need for control over others.

Thus, the obsessional’s inordinate pursuit of control over others is a multidetermined behavioral pathway, as are most major personality characteristics.

The following discussion focuses upon only the first two types of control over others: (a) an exaggerated need to influence favorably the opinions of others, and (b) the need to be the major determiner of the conditions of one’s interpersonal interactions. Manifestations of these two concerns are especially pervasive and important clinically.

The Need to Influence Positively

By far the major way in which the obsessive seeks to enhance others’ regard for him is by thinking, feeling and acting in a fashion he deems unassailable. Usually, therefore, he demonstrates behavior that conforms to perceived environmental expectations, especially along the axes of morality and achievement. Such behavior usually suits defensive needs, too, including those against erotic or aggressive impulses. Thus, the obsessive may seem honest to a fault, prompt, conscientious, loyal, cautious, outwardly compliant or agreeable, perfectionistic, clever and capable. Similarly, he may avoid endeavors carrying the risk of failure, especially in areas he judges significant. At times, this leaves him very few choices. If his performance in one of his “strong suits” is flawed, his artistry at rationalization can be stunning.

In other words, unable to tolerate an unfavorable verdict, the obsessive attempts to leave no room for blame. Those thoughts, actions, or feelings of which he disapproves, or expects others to disapprove - lust, anger, self-indulgence, laziness, etc. - he represses, suppresses, or acts upon in a camouflaged way, one that has an impact, yet defies culpability. For example, an obsessional secretary, privately resenting her employer’s demands, was unable to type his (crucial) letter because she was “too busy” with his other (trivial) work.

Besides enhancing others’ judgment of him, the obsessional expects additional advantages from his above-blame behavior. For instance, it affords him a self-righteous, or holier-than-thou position relative to others. From there he can control their treatment of him by provoking guilt.

In addition, the speech-oriented type of obsessional discovers early that a magical tool, language, enables him to mould the opinions of would-be critics into favorable attitudes (Sullivan, 1956). Thus the obsessional controls others’ view of him via knowing and ostensibly adhering to the rules of his social system and via perfectionism and the skilled manipulation of the powerful tool of language.

The Need for Control Games

The second kind of control over others - the need to determine the time, place and nature of interpersonal interactions - seems to stem partly from fears of vulnerability to malevolence or disregard, and from fears of having one’s sense of a separate identity overrun. Often this need manifests itself in behavior that others may view negatively; thus it is paradoxical, in that it conflicts with the aim of the first type of control over others, which brings positive reactions. For example, the obsessional must be the one who decides when and how a conversation will begin, proceed, and end. Others must not get the idea that he can be walked over, or that he is insignificant, lest they make it a practice to disregard his ideas, feelings, well-being, or his very existence.

Thus the obsessive is noticeably early or late for meetings or appointments; controlling or obstructive in his manner of interacting; and insistent upon controlling the ending or having the last word. If the therapist signals the end of a session, for example, the obsessive patient may try to re-engage him/her, as though to gain command of the relationship before leaving. He may give the therapist an assignment - to ask the secretary for a form, to remember what is being talked about the next time, or to drive home carefully. One patient may ask for a wrap-up comment, to make the therapist perform; another wants to make “one more point”; and still another may give the therapist an evaluation, a grade on how well the session went. Though all of these behaviors are multidetermined and can occur in nonobsessives also, one consistent aim in the obsessional is to assuage his anxiety by assuming control over both the ending of the session and the tenor of the relationship.

Therapist comments such as, “We have to stop now,” can be experienced by the patient as frightening and humiliating reminders that the therapist, indeed, controls some aspects of the relationship, and that, as in childhood, the patient is again vulnerable. He may attempt to deny this reality by using his last-second maneuvers, in addition to his infamous controlling techniques in the session proper. Often he becomes secretly enraged at the therapist for the degree of power that he wields in the relationship.

In a romantic relationship, the obsessive must be the one who determines the duration, intensity, exclusivity, and range of acceptable behaviors of both parties. He also must maintain the “upper hand,” or its illusion, and avoid vulnerability - he must distance the partner rather than be distanced, judge rather than be judged, reject rather than be rejected, and terminate rather than be left. He must not risk. Perhaps above all, he must somehow guarantee that he will not be betrayed.

This sensitive romantic area poses a most poignant challenge to the myth that interpersonal experiences can be controlled, and specifically, that rejection can be avoided. Faced with a situation so crucial to his psychological equilibrium, yet one in which so little control actually rests with him, the obsessive battles anxiety. At such times he might, to maintain the illusion of control, invoke the magical power of control games, such as covert contracts. For instance, if he is afraid of betrayal, he may remain rigidly faithful, even to the point of having no opposite-sex friends. He thus binds his mate, he thinks, by some moral code; but it exists only in his own mind. His notion rests upon a second defensive myth, that of fairness. “The world is just,” he reasons, “and people get what they deserve; therefore, if I am rigidly faithful, I cannot be betrayed. She must also be faithful to me.” Given this unconscious irrational notion, romantic infidelity by his partner elicits in the obsessional, among other painful affects, self-righteous indignation and vindictiveness. Moreover, anxiety, a drop in self-esteem, humiliation, or depression may occur.

Miscellaneous Control

Just as he pursues control over himself and others, the obsessional pursues verification of his myth of a third kind of control, wherein he can protect himself against all of life’s potential dangers and difficulties. These include illness, accidents, poverty, natural disasters, political upheavals, and death. Discussion of this pursuit will focus, first, upon the obsessional’s general attitude towards experience and, second, upon the illusory control gained through his search for order.

General Attitude

The obsessional usually assumes a cautious, expectant, or vigilant attitude toward life’s possible exigencies. He may keep well-informed about events that could affect him, to circumvent perceived incipient danger. The unknown frightens him and he avoids it whenever possible. Uncertain as to the outcome of a situation that will involve him, yet unable to avoid involvement, he may adopt a defensive pessimism. By predicting the worst, he avoids vulnerability to any unexpected misfortune. Should the worst occur, he can say that he predicted the outcome. This gives at least the illusion of having had some form of control.

Order

Miscellaneous control, or its illusion, is also pursued through a preoccupation with order and organization. Chaos, ambiguity, and the unexpected are feared and avoided. The obsessive tries, or at least wishes, to keep himself and his possessions in an orderly pattern. He may insist, for example, that his equipment, gadgets, watch, car, and other potentially useful belongings be kept in good working condition. In this way he reassures himself that life in its broader respects, too, can be ordered and, therefore, controlled. In addition, thus fortified and “ready for anything,” he feels less vulnerable to potential damage occasioned by the unexpected. He may also feel that, should he devise and follow certain rituals, he will be assured of good health. He may even believe, at an unconscious level, that he can avoid death altogether, if only he gives the problem enough time, thought, and effort.

Similarly, the obsessive may gravitate toward endeavors that affirm an illusory acquisition of control, and shun “fuzzier” ones. He believes that he can someday solve, via intellectual effort and ultimate understanding, the governing laws of the universe. For example, he is particularly attracted to work involving the “hard” sciences, gadgets, measurements, the accumulation of facts or data, comparisons, answers, problem-solving, and technical performance, even in his leisure time. These provide avenues for repetitive rituals that exercise a sense of control. Manipulating, categorizing, measuring and otherwise ordering representative bits of the universe at large - data, matter, numerical ratios, energies, ideas, etc. - are reassuring to him, providing symbolic confirmation of his illusion that ultimately - through alertness, discovery, reason and effort - he can predict or otherwise control the behavior of his universe.

Conversely, the obsessive may shy away from areas of experience that do not lend themselves to such ordering operations. Human relationships, or the experience or display of feelings, his own or others’, may puzzle and frighten him. These matters defy efforts at ordering, categorizing and quantifying. Typically, the obsessional may complain, I can understand anything but relationships with people. I can’t figure out what (my spouse or mate) wants from me. How should I act? How does one decide this?” His pursuit of a blueprint in this area is, of course, futile. Nonetheless, he strives incessantly to derive formulas for “correct” behavior and interpersonal interaction. He does not trust spontaneity.

As mentioned earlier, the obsessive also attempts to control the universe by assigning it order with the rigid notion of naturally occurring fairness or justice. He cannot tolerate the idea that those forces determining our fortunes can be haphazard or uncontrollable at times. To him, accepting this viewpoint means acknowledging a terrifying total lack of control over what happens to him. He therefore clings to a fantasied powerful universal justice, which permits him the illusion of control. Whether religiously affiliated or not, he envisions an omniscient, omnipresent and omnipotent force, a Scorekeeper that evens things up. People, then, get what they deserve. If he can pile up “accounts receivable” in his private ledger, he reasons, he ensures himself good fortune. The Scorekeeper is in his debt. IOU’s may be accumulated through self-denial, sacrifice, industry, diligence, purity, honesty, loyalty, and through avoiding behavior, thoughts or feelings that seem aggressive, selfish, hedonistic, “dirty,” or even enjoyable. Such “negative” behaviors can represent “collections” or transgressions that detract from, cancel out or overshoot what is owed him.

Should he intend to engage in a self-seeking behavior, he may need to “pay his dues” first, by performing some unpleasant or painful, but noble, duty. And if he has experienced “unearned” pleasure or good fortune, anticipating the inevitable score-evening blow, he may become anxious. The anxiety may be such that, to fend it off, he either represses awareness of his own pleasure, or behaves self-destructively in order to wrest an illusory control from the Scorekeeper. Often the self-seeking wish, being sexual or otherwise “immoral,” is repressed. Only a defensive prohibition, in the form of a reaction-formation (e.g., abstinence, overly solicitous behavior, compulsive rituals, etc.), may be available to consciousness.

Likewise, should the obsessive live a life of meticulous self-denial, yet never receive the expected payoffs, he becomes outraged or bitter. Angry, violent or blaming fantasies may arise involving his parents, other authority figures, religious institutions or the therapist. He feels misled and betrayed by life in general, since he is unaware that it is his own defensive need to maintain the illusion of order and fairness that has generated his expectations. Of the insights that might occur in therapy, none is more painful for the obsessive, or more difficult to accept, than the awareness that the world is not fair!

Shapiro (1965) observes that the obsessional often seems more intent upon taxing himself on a task (i.e., trying) than upon accomplishing it. In my view, the obsessive’s need to appear industrious, and the primacy of effort in his hierarchy, are motivated partly by the fairness doctrine. The obsessional expects the Scorekeeper to compensate him for good intentions and for effort, regardless of results - for example, for trying to be prepared for misfortune, or even for worrying diligently. Similarly, if the obsessive is unmotivated, he anticipates punishment, as he does if results come too easily. If he tries at anything - school, therapy, staying healthy, etc. - he may feel slighted and resentful if his efforts are not rewarded with success.

Testing The Myth

Often the obsessive will fear experiences that might contradict the myth in any of the three areas. Whenever possible, he avoids these situations, either literally or through distortion. Because of his need for self-control, he may get anxious whenever he experiences or faces romantic infatuation, angry or sexual feelings, hypnosis, general anesthesia, drug intoxication or even sleep. Such experiences can threaten him by undermining his vigilance, making him vulnerable to all those internal and external threats mentioned at the outset.

He also gets anxious whenever he does not feel in control of his relationships with others. For example, if he cannot prevent someone from disapproving of him, disliking him, being angry with him, rejecting him or doubting his capabilities or character, he cannot just “let it go.” This can occur even when the other person is not at all central or important in his life. He may ruminate upon the situation to the point of being unable to sleep or concentrate until he resolves it. And despite his usually remarkable capacity for unassailable behavior and opinion-moulding tactics, it is impossible to measure up to everyone’s expectations, and to exemplify everyone’s idea of virtue. In other words, the endeavor is untenable, and in striving for the impossible, the obsessive sets himself up for pain.

With the second form of control over others - the need to dictate all aspects of interaction with them - difficulties also arise. In romantic relationships, for instance, he is bothered when confronted with evidence that contradicts his belief that he can control his partner. His first line of defense may be to avoid intimate relationships, or select partners who are easily controlled. Once involved, though, if his controlling tactics do not work, and he finds the partner holding the upper hand, he becomes anxious, suspicious, and even enraged. Frequently, his fear of betrayal or rejection prompts him to end the relationship first, to maintain the illusion of control.

Out of his need to dictate the conditions and content of practically all personal interactions, he can make himself difficult to get along with. He may alienate people, including friends, therapists, and romantic partners.

Self-defeat also shadows the obsessional’s attempts to pursue his myth of potentially total control over life’s miscellaneous circumstances. Despite his precautions, he may become ill or injured; suffer a financial catastrophe; experience unexpected malfunction in a vehicle, machine or system upon which he depends. At such times, he may experience disproportionate anxiety, not so much from the specific immediate blow (i.e., the illness or malfunction) as from the frightening brief awareness that his myth is incorrect - that despite his best caution, vigilance, and prophylactic efforts, he cannot completely control his health, financial well-being, safety, etc.

Retroactive Control

The obsessive uses a particularly interesting mechanism whenever the myth of miscellaneous control fails. He invokes still another myth. We can call it the myth of “retroactive control.” The contractions “should’ve,” “could’ve,” and “would’ve,” are essential for this. He “should’ve” done this or that, and not done the other. If he had, he “would’ve” been better off. He “could’ve” struck it rich, avoided the flu, or performed better.

These contractions, representing his chronic second-guessing, illustrate the obsessive’s retroactive attempts to rearrange frighteningly disagreeable facts. They provide an escape route from the truth that one’s control over life is frequently imperfect at best. Should he catch a cold, immediately he searches for, and usually finds, a good reason - a draft he “should’ve” avoided, too little sleep, etc. Even when it would have been impossible to act differently, he insists that he not only could have, but should have. This maneuver alone permits him to maintain, retroactively, the illusion of control, even when it has been clearly disproved.

To the observer, he appears unduly angry with himself for having made this or that “mistake.” He seems to be manifesting evidence of low self-esteem in his self-criticism. However, just the opposite is often true. That is, he is protecting his defensive grandiose notion of control. He is angry only because he should have known better. His apparent self-criticisms and his anger with himself attest to a belief that he can be, and should be, above making mistakes.

Understandably, the therapist may take the self-criticism/self-esteem axis as the major issue. Certainly, self-esteem issues are crucial in the therapy of obsessionals. However, in the instance described above, the patient might successfully keep the therapist away from the more pertinent problem - the patient’s unreasonable defensive belief that he can and should maintain complete control of everything that happens to him, and his underlying terror.

His insistence upon the myth of miscellaneous control can lead the obsessional into still more difficulties. Upon such occasions as an acquaintance’s unexpected death, an earthquake, a plane crash, etc., he may experience both anxiety and rage. These events momentarily drive home, even to the obsessional, the fact that often life is not fair; that sometimes there appears to be no rhyme or reason; that therefore one wields only imperfect control over one’s life or death.

It hurts him when the control myth fails (is proven false), but the obsessive’s rigid attempts to verify it are also intrinsically damaging. For example, his rigid personal posture of self-control can become an increasingly life-constricting role, from which he cannot deviate. Often he wishes, appropriately, that he could “just let go” - be freer, more flexible, more spontaneous. But his fears of humiliation, of some vague retribution, of losing control totally, and of change itself will not let him. His in-control posture has become a source of pride that he cannot jeopardize. His inflexible need to enhance his image in the eyes of others might be self-damaging, even if attainable. The need to be above criticism requires constant, chameleon-like, self-betrayal. This contributes to a weakened sense of identity, reduced self-esteem, and general feelings of powerlessness. It can also create conflict with the obsessional’s other defensive requirements, such as being perfectly honest, strong of character, uncompromising or rigid in his values, and totally self-reliant.

In summary, experiences contradicting the obsessional’s belief in his capacity to maintain complete control over all aspects of his life can precipitate anxiety and/or other psychiatric symptoms. Symptoms result primarily not so much from the direct impact of the precipitating event as from its indirect effects. That is, the obsessional may experience such events as jeopardizing or invalidating a cherished building block of his sense, not only of safety and security, but also of self-esteem and pride.

In addition, the rigid pursuit of control is intrinsically self-damaging in all three of the discussed areas of experience. The exaggerated need for self-control rarely permits the obsessive to enjoy leisurely relaxation, to be spontaneous or creative, to abandon himself to the pleasures in life, or to pursue his aims whole-heartedly, vigorously, effectively and without anxiety. He is imprisoned within the defensive role he has carved out for himself. His unreasonable pursuit of control over others, instead of guaranteeing freedom from rejection or disapproval, causes him to pursue mutually exclusive goals, lose respect for himself, and isolate himself by alienating people.

Finally, pursuit of control over his miscellaneous universe is also doomed. Some aspects of life simply areuncontrollable and unpredictable, and death is inevitable. Single-minded attempts to deny his relative powerlessness in the universe involve life-constricting vigilance and caution; defensive pessimism, incompatible with enjoying the moment; intolerance of ambiguity, surprise and feelings; and a defensive Scorekeeper/fairness doctrine that hurts him in many ways. For example, rigid attempts to place the Score-keeper in his debt not only preclude pleasure and promote self-destructive acts, but also impede the obsessive’s capacity to accept the injustices inherent in living - a capacity that is an absolute prerequisite to experiencing the joys that remain despite life’s imperfections.

References available in original article on PEP.

Next
Next

Development and Initial Validation of the Pathological Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Scale for Children (POPS-C)